So I got my dissertation back from Advisor. I have to rework Chapt. 1 and the intro, all the rest is fine. Good, I knew that was the part I would have to work on, not only because I felt that it was maybe weak but also because Advisor really didn't read it carefully the first time around.
Advisor was supposed to meet me to explain me some of the points she marked but because her meeting run late, she was an hour late (I understand) and then she couldn't be with me because she had to have lunch with a colleague. OK, we agreed that I would call her for the stuff I couldn't understand, even at home. Pretty fair.
Then she looked at me and she said: "well, another thing, you are quoting a lot of authors in English or French, I just feel that because you are writing in language XYZ (my mother tongue) you should translate all your quotes because I think the Faculty demands that"..................
??????????????????????????????????????????????????
Hello?????????????????????????????????????????????
Couldn't we have asked the question before? I have to know NOW??????????
She told me she was not sure what the rules are so I should ask someone. I consulted two other dissertations from friends that finished 3 and 2 years ago. One did translate everything, the other one quoted in the original language. Plus, isn't this country bilingual? I am not quoting in Chinese here, only in English and French....
So I went upstairs and I asked the secretary: she told me that you can not substitute yourself for a translator, but jut to be sure she told me to call Graduate Studies. I did, I asked, and the person I spoke to assumed the same thing but she asked the Vice-Dean who gave her the same answer: no need to translate. Thank you!
But... wasn't she supposed to know this stuff? I am not her first Ph.D. student. I understand all the rules and regulations are boring but hey, that's definitely NOT my part. As for the quoting style: I asked her a while ago should I use MLA, Chicago, the French style some of the people use if they write in French? She didn't have a clue. I asked again the secretary: she didn't know either. So I consulted old dissertations: I didn't find two that were using the same style. We have no rules!!!!!! OK, much better, at least for me, but doesn't someone knows about this stuff?
And, I know that lunch maybe was important, but spending 15 minutes with your student would be a nice thing to do too (I couldn't make it this afternoon because I had to pick up the furry monster who is sleeping at my feet with his stitches showing...poor thing, but at least he is very joyful and happy to be home).
Now I am scared... what if her job is not good enough? What if she didn't correct stuff that was important? What if I should have read more? I basically did all by myself (corrections excluded) but I never spent time with her really discussing my subject.
To make a long story short: I hope I learn from all this and one day I'll make a better job at advising students........ I can't wait to be done with all this....